Title: The Three Pigs
Author: David Wiesner
Publisher: Clarion Books
Date: 2001
Number of pages: 40
Reading level: Ages 4-8
Genre: Children's Picture Book
My Reaction: I thought this was an excellent twist to the classic story. I didn't expect what was coming, so the witty and silly illustrations were really a surprise. I felt that the illustrations (like a comic) helped me get into the story and keep track of which story was which. Although it was semi- busy, the text and comic view-points helped the reader keep the story altogether.
Potential Problems: Being that the illustrations are busy it may be difficult for the younger readers to stay enthused in the storybook as they are very distracted with the different stories on each page. It can probably be confusing for children to differ from the original story, although fun.
My Recommendation: This book would best fit in a children's classroom reading time. I would assume it would be best understood with a teacher reading aloud to the children as they can hear the words, and watch the story unfold before them. The illustrations present a great picture for what is going on in the text of the story.
No comments:
Post a Comment